MY NAME IS BOB AND I AM AN IDIOT
Anyway, this is what I voted, before deletion, without the (un)funny commentary
Best game. Red Dead. Top 5 - RDR / Bayonetta / Split/Second / Fallout / Mass Effect 2
Best character Bonny McFarlane
Worst game that people thought was good. Enslaved. Garbage.
Best multiplayer. NFS:HP
Best moment. Taking down the seven players in front of you by destroying the dam in Split Second
Best Arcade game Monkey Island 2 (closely followed by Limbo and Comic Jumper)
Worst story. Castlevania. Not for the story but the awful, awful, portentous script.